888-983-1617 [email protected]

Help Me With When to Make an Employee an Owner of my Company

Ask Us Anything

Dear Oaklyn Consulting,

I’ve been in business for 10 years and have an employee who is a valued member of the business and would be hard to replace. How can I incentivize him/her to stay and become part of the equity in the business, while best protecting my interests?

 

From Oaklyn Consulting

You have two separate issues at work here: incentives for a key employee and what it means to be “part of the equity of the business.”

It’s not unusual for people to mix the issues of ownership and employment. However, in our experience, it’s hard to get to solutions when entrepreneurs don’t think about the issues distinctly. This isn’t to say that you can’t solve a compensation need with ownership, just that one topic isn’t necessarily related to the other.

For partnership and team-building questions, I respect the perspective of Greg Alexander, author of The Boutique: How to Start, Scale, and Sell a Professional Services Firm and the founder of Capital54. Greg says, “An employee who has been with you for 10 years is unlikely a flight risk. Ten years is a long time, and he/she has proven to not be a mercenary lured away by the highest bidder. Be careful not to create an issue where there isn’t one. If the employee is a flight risk, dig into what has changed in his/her life. Loyal employees don’t wake up someday after a decade and say ‘I am outta here.’ Something changed. By understanding the root cause, you can address the issue accurately. For instance, maybe equity is not the answer. It could be the employee is bored and instead of granting equity to retain him/her, maybe a new role would be more effective.”

From the perspective of capital decisions, we would add, regardless of why you want to add an incentive component to the employee relationship, be careful that “part of the equity” will actually create the alignment you want. The aspects of a company’s business that accrue to equity holders reflect both the operating and non-operating decisions about the company, and specifically decisions about capitalization (how much debt to take on our pay off), taxes (how to account for revenue and capital expenditures), voting rights in the event of a major dispute, and successor ownership in the event that an owner dies. If engagement in these aspects of the business are not the ones that will motivate your employee, maybe try something else, like bonuses, profit sharing or as Greg advises, a role change.

We're Here to Help

Have a question for Oaklyn Consulting? Enter your question below and we will incorporate your question and our response into an upcoming edition. 


News & Insights

How We Help Investment Bankers Say Yes More Often

How We Help Investment Bankers Say Yes More Often

In investment banking, credibility is everything. If you’ve developed a reputation for successfully executing deals, having deep industry knowledge and being a trustworthy partner, your investment banking expertise might be highly sought after. While it’s great to...

Putting Together a Seamless Transition Plan

Ask Us Anything Dear Oaklyn Consulting, I started a nonprofit 8 years ago after my son passed so that I could create an impact while honoring him. We’ve been able to grow and help thousands of individuals. I am getting to the point of retirement and want to figure...

Help Me With Options For Obtaining Capital

Ask Us Anything Dear Oaklyn Consulting, I have a business that needs a cash inflow. However, my local bank is not willing to provide more credit. What other options do I have to obtain capital, and what are the pros and cons of each alternative?   From Oaklyn...

Oaklyn Consulting

Selling and Retirement

Ask Us Anything Dear Oaklyn Consulting, I’m 61 years old and have been working in/running my business for 40 years. I want to retire and I don’t know if I can find a buyer that will pay enough to allow me to retire comfortably on the proceeds. What options should I...

Oaklyn Consulting

Is Now The Right Time To Sell My Business?

Ask Us Anything Dear Oaklyn Consulting, For the last five years, I’ve been making 65% to 75% gross profit. I know in the next few years, gross profit is going to shrink because of new competition coming into the market. What advice do you have for me to consider...

Oaklyn Consulting

How to Navigate Business Debt and Equity Options

When closely held businesses need capital, they generally have two options — getting a bank loan or seeking out private investors. While a loan isn’t going to be a viable solution for every liquidity need a business has, it can be significantly less expensive in...

Oaklyn Consulting

Help Me With a Conflict in My Family Business

Ask Us Anything Dear Oaklyn Consulting, Three members of our family business (a father and two sons) are not getting along. The father isn't retiring and wants to control the business, while the sons would like to sell the business. What advice do you have for the...

Oaklyn Consulting

Help Me With a Succession Plan

Ask Us Anything Dear Oaklyn Consulting, It’s been a really hard year. I own a business that I’ve been successfully running for the last 15 years. I’ve had some health troubles that have pushed me to a position where my doctors are suggesting that I need to retire...

Help Me With Acquiring a Business

Help Me With Acquiring a Business

Ask Us Anything Dear Oaklyn Consulting, I am a business owner who has a substantial local presence. I’m considering acquiring a competitor that has a larger presence outside my current market. This move would expand our footprint immediately and give us the...