888-983-1617 [email protected]

How to Talk to Your Banker and Investors During Uncertain Times

NOTE: This blog was written in March 2020.
I’m now four recessions into my career. Each one is different, and this is the first one associated with a health crisis. But in some ways, they follow a similar pattern — signs of strain followed by crisis, complacency and then extended trouble.

Think about the Great Recession: rising mortgage defaults for almost a year, a very dramatic few weeks in early September 2008, a period of quiet ending with a new cycle of bad news in March 2009, and finally, a struggle to restart growth around the globe for years.

Or the 2000-01 recession, starting with the dot-com bust; then 9/11; then the collapses of Enron, Worldcom and Global Crossing; then the changes in our lives from the war on terror.

Right now, our first job, obviously, is the safety of our employees, our communities, our families and ourselves.

Soon, for all of us who manage commercial organizations, our primary focus will shift to protecting liquidity, preserving financial sustainability and finding the best ways to have an impact in the world.

My career has been spent in finance jobs, so I have a money-oriented perspective. A lesson I have taken from previous recessions is that one of business leaders’ most important responsibilities is demonstrating confidence and competence to capital partners. Yet this is a job that many executives fail at.

In times like this, how do you talk to your banker and investors? Here are six things that I have seen work and that our firm helps clients with:

 

1. Establish a sustainable whole-of-the-company decision-making process, communicate the process, and use it to make a living plan.

Get all the right members of senior management in the room (either physically or online) regularly to discuss issues and solutions across the entire company. Get your arms around the most significant issues, set a direction that you can course-correct as needed and communicate both the direction “for now” and the expectation that you will adjust as conditions necessitate. Identify the drivers that will indicate the need to change, monitor these drivers and course-correct the plan by relying on a steady decision-making process. Therefore, the decision-making process will be consistent even as the details of the plan itself change.

 

2. Quantify scenarios for the sake of your own decision-making and to communicate the range of possible outcomes.

Disciplined scenario thinking makes a difference in uncertain times. How much money could I lose? When could I run out of cash and why? How can I mitigate these risks and at what cost? What unexamined assumptions about the company’s operations could prove false and cause trouble? For how long?

Now is the time, obviously, to manage the business with a financial projection model that includes a detailed cash forecast.

But it is also the time to develop a range of plausible scenarios about the future, quantify them and assess your resilience across all of them. The goal of scenario thinking is not to choose between several plans, but to have one living plan that can help you navigate the situation. Good scenario thinking supports a steady decision-making process and helps you prepare for and communicate the range of outcomes.

 

3. Show what you’re already doing.

We recently heard this suggestion from one banker: “If you can describe what the problem is, and ideally estimate how long it will last, that’s good. Your bank can defer payments or go interest-only if they believe that you have your arms around the issues and are creditworthy.” So, your words and actions need to communicate that you already have your arms around the issues, and that your judgment deserves support. Without delay, make the decisions that need to be made, and put them in context for your banker and investors.

 

4. Speak credibly.

The ideal tone to strike should be humble, balanced and fact-based. Some investors call it “clinically realistic.” Its main characteristic is that you don’t add to the panic by coming across as either complacent or out of control. A private equity investor reminded us that investors and banks “will lose all confidence if their credits set their own hair on fire.”

Equally, says another, calmly bring problems to light “so that they can be addressed now rather than remaining in the dark corners to grow mold and become deeper situations later on.”

 

5. Ask for your capital partners’ help, listen to them and adjust your plans.

Remember that your investors, board directors and bankers have probably talked with more CEOs than you have, and that they can see patterns invisible to any one company. Make full use of the professional relationship between companies and capital partners to add to everyone’s knowledge so that you all can learn and adjust.

Appreciate that bankers work for highly regulated companies, and that investors have portfolio-wide reserves and risks to manage. Understand that banks’ and investors’ own businesses change, so some who appear to be the right partner now might not always be, even if they say they want to keep working with you into the future. If your current capital partners are not the right ones to get you through the situation, respectfully start looking for new partners now.

 

6. When the issues are under control, let your banker and investors know you are ready to go on offense.

Just as a moving bike is easier to balance on, a growing business is more stable. As quickly and candidly as possible, deal with the issues destabilizing you. Then start scanning for organic and acquisitive growth opportunities. Some opportunities will exist only momentarily. For example, as your peers are also assessing their liquidity needs in the midst of a crisis, maybe a business combination — if they know to think about it — is a better outcome than the recapitalization or operating changes they will otherwise need to do.

 

HOW OAKLYN CONSULTING CAN HELP

We can help organize your war-room approach.

  • Acting as chief of staff, setting the agenda, clarifying work streams and framing decisions
  • Establishing a rhythm for the “new normal.”
  • Articulating a living business plan.
  • Tracking changes in conditions.

 

We can assist you in making major decisions by modeling plausible scenarios and doing financial planning and analysis.

  • Assessing company exposure and doing in-depth analysis across a variety of scenarios.
  • Structuring a discussion about scenarios that affect near-term decisions, and supporting it with quantitative analysis.
  • Defining the drivers and monitoring them, bringing the perspective into regularly updated financial projections.
  • Outlining actions triggered by worsening scenarios.

 

We can facilitate communications with investors and creditors.

  • Creating in-depth, granular financial statement analysis and projection scenarios to help you, your Board directors, lenders and investors to make informed, realistic decisions.
  • Reviewing your script and plans as you prepare for banker, Board of Directors and investor meetings.
  • Drafting investor memorandums and organize the responses to information requests
  • When necessary, managing the process of raising capital from new lenders or investors

 

When the timing is appropriate, we can help you go on offense.

  • Scanning for organic and acquisitive growth opportunities.
  • Organizing acquisition prospecting, analysis and due diligence efforts.
  • When needed, seeking and marketing to new capital partners, whether banks or investors.

Oaklyn Consulting Congratulates Finite Reimaging on Acquisition by CAMP Construction Services

Oaklyn Consulting helped AMP Construction Services acquire Finite Reimaging. Learn it all here.

Help Me Develop a Sellable Asset

Ask Us Anything Dear Oaklyn Consulting, I don’t know if it’s the economy or the time of year, but it feels like every time I turn around, there is another M&A firm calling to see if I am in the market to sell my small business. I know that this is something that I...

Consulting vs. Investment Banking: Which Approach Suits Your Business Needs?

Understand the main differences between investment banking and consulting. Get the best services for your business and unlock new opportunities.

Help Me With Selling a Business

Ask Us Anything Dear Oaklyn Consulting, I have a friend who is selling their existing business, and they want more than any buyer is willing to pay. Should they take the best terms they can get, regardless of their “valuation,” and ride off into the sunset or wait...

How to Assess Non-Profit Financial Performance: A Step-By-Step Guide

Gauge your organization’s financial health effectively. See how to assess non-profit financial performance and unlock more opportunities to accomplish your mission.

Help Me With My Seasonal Business

Ask Us Anything Dear Oaklyn Consulting, I operate a seasonal business that relies heavily on tourism and favorable weather conditions. When the weather cooperates, our company is exceptionally profitable. However, the weather hasn't been on our side for the past two...

Help With My Family Business

Ask Us Anything Dear Oaklyn Consulting, I've been running our family's small business and have been for the last 5 years. While we are an established brand who has been successful in business for over 20 years, this year is hard. Sales aren’t growing as projected....

How to Spot Warning Signs that a Deal Is in Danger

Read the article in The Middle Market.Bringing an M&A deal across the finish line can be a long and perilous road. No matter how certain a transaction might initially seem, there’s always the possibility that one party can abruptly change its plans and drop out —...

What to Do When It’s Hard to Sell Your Business (Niche or Not)

Read the article in The American Genius.There are many hurdles that can arrive when you are trying to sell your business – here are some tips to meet yours and your buyer’s needs. Having a profitable business is no guarantee that you’ll one day be able to easily sell...

3 Signs an M&A Deal Is in Trouble

Read the article in CFO.Spotting signs of trouble early is critical for CFOs to prevent a deal from derailing. Not every CFO will experience M&A firsthand during their career. But those who do typically find that their existing skillset makes them a crucial asset...