888-983-1617 [email protected]

Takeaways from Axial’s Recent ‘Dead Deals’ Analysis

Those of us who negotiate M&A transactions for, and with, small- to mid-sized businesses know a few hallmarks of the process:

  • For any company, there is a limited universe of buyers.
  • Each buyer’s interest is unique, so average valuations are not reliable indicators of value, except as guideposts.
  • The negotiation process is long, with six points when terms can change materially:
    1. Initial interest. Was everyone who should know about the opportunity aware?
    2. Initial bids. Has the seller put its best foot forward?
    3. Letters of intent. Have the seller and buyer come to agreement on all relevant business terms, based on what they had each known/shared to this point?
    4. Conclusion of due diligence. After the opportunity to investigate the seller’s business in detail, was the buyer able to validate its assumptions?
    5. Conclusion of the buyer’s financing. Was the buyer able to convince its financing sources of the deal?
    6. Presentation of legal documents. When added to the business terms of the deal, were the legal terms and details still agreeable to all parties?
  • The further a deal progresses, the harder it gets to walk away.

Practitioners know these things by intuition and experience, which leads to a feel for the market. There are few publicly disclosed details about small- to mid-sized business transaction terms to observe. So any validation of experts’ pattern recognition can be quite valuable. That’s why we appreciate market participants who find ways to create data-supported insights.

Axial, the lower middle-market deal sourcing platform, is one of our favorites because of the data their platform generates and the curiosity with which they dig into trends.

Some market data has shown that small- to mid-sized M&A deal volume stayed high in 2021 and 2022, but the number and value of closed deals fell.

In a recently published piece, Axial tried to determine the reasons why, examining data from its platform related to deals that failed post-LOI (see steps 4-6 above). As part of its approach, Axial also surveyed members about what happened with individual deals. It received 48 responses with telling answers:

  1. Macro trends were occasionally the cause, but MOSTLY NOT.
  2. Interest rates and the availability of capital were occasionally the cause, but MOSTLY NOT.
  3. Choices about information disclosure (i.e. the deal process) were MOSTLY the cause. Half of the time, one party learned something in due diligence that changed their vision of opportunity (see step 4 above).
  4. Real life is persistently a factor — one-third of the time, the parties backed away from the agreement for unspecified reasons, presumably because they simply had better alternatives than closing the deal. For example, “Seller said he didn’t appreciate how much he and his family benefited from the business until going through the sale process.”

Why does this matter right now? First, the macro news has been bad, with rising interest rates, M&A deal values down, a possible looming recession and bank failures. But if you’re wavering on whether to move forward on a deal, don’t let those events be your excuse. There is ample capital to complete strategically relevant M&A transactions, so you can get deals done.

Second, good times or bad, preparation makes a difference. The seller can do a lot to manage the risk of broken deals by being ready, understanding what buyers need to know and candidly providing the information. If you’re an entrepreneur-owner-manager or investor and are unsure whether it’s the right time to sell, or how to go about doing that, an experienced advisor can help provide guidance.

3 Signs an M&A Deal Is in Trouble

Read the article in CFO.Spotting signs of trouble early is critical for CFOs to prevent a deal from derailing. Not every CFO will experience M&A firsthand during their career. But those who do typically find that their existing skillset makes them a crucial asset...

4 Tips for Pitching Investors in Today’s Economy

Read the article in CFO.Any company that intends to grow past a certain point eventually reaches the familiar milestone of pitching to private capital sources in hopes of securing additional funding. Those businesses that tend to be most successful are the ones that...

Resolving Conflicts in a Family Business

Read the article in Small Business Current.When family members run a business together, the experience often draws them closer, but there are inherent risks as well. Having years of personal history with one’s co-workers can sometimes lead to non-work disputes...

Oaklyn Consulting Congratulates Proof of the Pudding on Acquisition by Bruin Capital

Oaklyn Consulting congratulates Atlanta-based catering, food service and event company Proof of the Pudding on its recent acquisition by Bruin Capital. Oaklyn Consulting assisted Proof of the Pudding in evaluating potential partners and negotiating the transaction....

Analyzing Broad vs. Narrow M&A Deal Processes

We respect the unique M&A market insights that Sutton Place Strategies, an affiliate of Bain & Company, creates from its business development work with PE firms. SPS Founder and CEO Nadim Malik gave a presentation at ACG Boston's M&A Outlook forum in...

How To Work Through Conflicts In a Family Business

Creating a family business comes with a lot of positives, as well as a lot of challenges. Here’s how to handle those conflicts as they arise. Thanks to The American Genius for having me! Read the article in PDF.Anyone who’s managed a business with other family members...

Who We Helped in 2022

At the start of every year, we at Oaklyn Consulting like to look back at the past 12 months to reflect on projects accomplished and lessons learned from our clients. Building on our achievements from 2021, Oaklyn Consulting worked with 34 organizations in 2022 on...

Monty Bruell Interview with Business Radio X

Our Monty Bruell sat down with Business Radio X to discuss succession planning in minority and women-owned businesses. Listen on Spotify or Amazon Music or read the transcript below!INTRO: Broadcasting live from the business RadioX Studios in Atlanta, Georgia, it's...

Succession Planning for Minority and Female Business Owners

For the founders of minority and women-owned business enterprises (MWBEs), succession planning takes on a deeper significance. Our Monty Bruell explains in a guest column for Memphis Business Journal. Read the article in PDF.Any entrepreneur approaching retirement has...

Oaklyn’s Leah Williams Featured in Business Insider; She Shares 5 Strategies for Crafting Memorable Pitch Decks

We were proud to see our own Leah Williams recently spotlighted in Business Insider! Leah joined Oaklyn in June 2021 as an investor communications consultant and helps us with the important work of crafting persuasive, compelling pitch decks to help our clients tell...